“At Concord Academy, environmental sustainability is not just a goal set out in our mission; it’s a fundamental part of our identity.” These words are posted on the CA website, emblazoned in big letters for the world to see, and from solar panels to a pollinator garden to our campus Micro-Farm, the school is working hard to make good on its values. Large sustainability initiatives such as these often take center stage, and for good reason: These developments are both physically impressive and highly impactful. But what if I told you that there was another sustainability superhero living on campus, one that you might be drinking from at this very moment? In addition to reusable cups, plates, and utensils, the Stu-Fac offers disposable alternatives for the school community to use, including compostable cups for hot and cold drinks.
Compostable plastics are designed to disintegrate over time, affecting the environment less than conventional plastics. Typically, plastic can take anywhere from a hundred to more than a thousand years to break down, but certified compostable plastics can decompose within twelve weeks at industrial facilities and can be added back into soil without causing harm to the environment. At a time when reducing our environmental impact is more urgent than ever, compostable plastic offers an exciting potential solution to the plastic waste crisis—but this solution comes with a few important asterisks.
For starters, most compostable plastics are not designed to break down independently. If you took a cup out of the Stu-Fac and tossed it behind the baseball diamond, it probably wouldn’t decompose effectively. Compostable plastics are tested to break down under controlled conditions, such as specific temperatures and oxygen levels. For instance, these materials require consistent temperatures of at least 122 degrees Fahrenheit to break down. CA sends its compost to Black Earth Compost, which is able to process these plastics under the required conditions, but home composting systems and many other composting facilities cannot provide the conditions necessary to do so.
Even when these materials can be composted, it is often difficult to distinguish between compostable and conventional plastics, so both may be removed from the compost stream. Compostable plastics removed in this way are sent to landfills, where they release methane, a greenhouse gas estimated to be roughly thirty times as potent as carbon dioxide.
Finally, increasing amounts of research suggest that compostable plastics do not fully degrade, leaving behind microplastics that can remain in the soil and infiltrate waterways and the food system. Some of these microplastics may contain toxic additives used in the manufacturing process, potentially causing widespread contamination. Although standards exist to promote safety, most only require 90 percent degradation of the plastics, allowing fragments to remain in the finished compost.
In the pursuit of environmental sustainability, compostable plastics are a strong step in the right direction, but they still face several limitations. Research on these materials’ long-term effects on the environment remains sparse, and the proper infrastructure for their disposal requires further investment. Next time you’re craving Bevi water or cranberry juice, consider pouring it into a reusable glass instead. Although compostable cups are less environmentally harmful than those made from conventional plastics, a reusable glass is still, at least for now, your safest bet.

