What does it mean to live like time is limited? How do you tell someone’s life story without letting the ending define everything that came before it? Just in Time, the new jukebox musical about 1950s singer Bobby Darin, explores these questions by focusing on energy, performance, and presence. Starring Frozen and Hamilton’s Jonathan Groff and directed by Alex Timbers, the production turns the Circle in the Square Theatre into an immersive nightclub, pulling the audience into Darin’s world rather than keeping them at a distance like an orthodox theatre.
The musical, which opened on April 26, 2025, follows Bobby Darin’s rise from a sickly child with a short life expectancy to one of the most recognizable performers of the 1950s and '60s. Instead of telling his story linearly, Just in Time moves through Darin’s life using his music as its guide. Songs like “Splish Splash” and “Mack the Knife” mark major moments in his career, portrayingboth his rapid success and his constant desire to achieve further. While the show does not ignore Darin’s health struggles or personal setbacks, it chooses to focus on his passion for performing and his refusal to slow down until it is inevitably too late.
Jonathan Groff’s performance is the clear highlight of the production. Rather than trying to perfectly imitate Bobby Darin, Groff chooses to introduce himself as Jonathan Groff before stepping into the role in the opening number. This sets the tone for the show: the audience is watching Groff act as Darin, not disappear into him completely. His charm and confidence fill the space, and his ability to move seamlessly between singing, dancing, and playing instruments keeps the show exciting and alive. At the same time, Groff allows moments of vulnerability to break through, reminding the audience that Darin was more than just a larger-than-life performer.
The supporting cast adds depth and emotional weight, especially the women in Darin’s life. Broadway newcomer Sadie Dickerson brings warmth and strength to her portrayal of Sandra Dee, a role originated by Erika Henningsen. Dickerson gives her character control over her own story rather than positioning her as just a part of Darin’s. Modern Family star Sarah Hyland stands out as Gracie Lawrence’s replacement for Connie Francis. She delivers a powerful performance that emphasizes both her talent and her stage presence. Michele Pawk also leaves a strong impression as Darin’s mother, who brings humor and heart to the show. Together, the ensemble supports Darin’s story to feel more well-rounded and human.
What makes Just in Time especially effective is its tone. While the show acknowledges that Darin died young, it does not let that fact overshadow the rest of his life. Instead of focusing on tragedy, the musical celebrates his ambition, creativity, and love for performing. The result is a show that feels joyful and heartfelt, even when it touches on more serious moments. Just in Time may follow the common structure of a biographical musical, but its strong cast, immersive design, and vibrancy help it stand out. With Jonathan Groff leading the way, the production becomes a full experience. By the end of the show, audiences are reminded of the importance of making the most of the time they have.